Logic and Philosophy of Time

Vol. 5 No. 1 (2023): The History and Philosophy of Tense-logic
Articles

Prior’s turn from determinism to indeterminism

pdf
  • Per Hasle,
  • Jakobsen David
Per Hasle
Department of Communication, University of Copenhagen
Jakobsen David
Department of Communication and Psychology, Aalborg University.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v5i1.7990

Published 23-10-2023

Keywords

  • Arthur Norman Prior,
  • free will,
  • determinism,
  • indeterminism,
  • foreknowledge,
  • Jonathan Edwards,
  • asymmetry of time
    • ...More
    Less

How to Cite

Hasle, P., & David, J. (2023). Prior’s turn from determinism to indeterminism. Logic and Philosophy of Time, 5(1). https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v5i1.7990

Copyright (c) 2023 Logic and Philosophy of Time

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Abstract

Indeterminism assumes a central place in Arthur Norman Prior’s invention and development of modern tense logic. Before this indeterminism, Prior was for a number of years a devout determinist. But Prior’s turn from determinism to indeterminism, so important for his mature work, has never been explained properly. This article presents the enigma of Prior’s turn from determinism to indeterminism. We know much about his early determinism and recently have learned more about how he became a determinist, but, apart from the fact that he in the course of the years between 1949 and 1953 became an indeterminist, we know very little about how or why he became an indeterminist and what exactly he then understood by free will and indeterminism. He never explained this himself at any length, but scattered remarks in various texts provide some aid in approaching this issue. We here take a look at some important texts in which Prior writes about the free will to help us a step further toward solving this riddle.

pdf

References

  1. Copeland, J. 1996. Logic and Reality: Essays in the Legacy of Arthur Prior. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  2. Bergson, H. 1950. Time and Free Will, Authorised Translation by F.L. Pogson (First Impression 1910), George Allen & Unwin Ltd., London.
  3. Findlay, J. N. 1936. ‘Relational properties’, The Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy, 14, 176–90. https://doi.org/10.1080/00048403608541077
  4. Grimshaw, M. 2018. Arthur Prior – ‘A Young Progressive’: Letters to Ursula Bethell & Hugh Teague 1936–1941. Christchurch: Canterbury University Press.
  5. Hasle., P. 1999. 'The Problem of Predestination – a Prelude to A. N. Prior's Tense Logic. In M. Wegener (Ed.), Time, Creation and World-Order (pp. 139-159). Aarhus University Press.
  6. Hasle, P., Jakobsen, D. & Øhrstrøm, P., Eds. 2020. The Metaphysics of Time: Themes from Prior, Volume 4 in the book series, Logic and Philosophy of Time, (Series editors: Per Hasle, Patrick Blackburn & Peter Øhrstrøm), Aalborg University Press. The_Metaphysics_of_Time_OA.pdf (aau.dk)
  7. Hasle, P. & Prior, M. 2003. ‘Life and work of Arthur N. Prior – An interview with Mary Prior’, in P. Hasle, P. Øhrstrøm, T. Braüner, J. Copeland, A.N. Prior, Papers on Time and Tense, 2nd and Ext. Edition, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 313–36.
  8. Hasker, W. (1998). God, Time and Knowledge. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
  9. https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501702907
  10. Jakobsen, D. & Øhrstrøm, P., Prior, M., Rini, A. Eds. 2020a. Three Little Essays: Arthur Prior in 1931, Volume 3 in the book series, Logic and Philosophy of Time, (Series editors: Per Hasle, Patrick Blackburn & Peter Øhrstrøm), Aalborg University Press. PRIOR3_OA.pdf (aau.dk)
  11. Jakobsen, D. 2020b. “Dispelling the Freudian Specter: A.N. Prior’s Discussion of Religion in 1943,” in [6]
  12. Jakobsen, D. 2020c. “A.N. Prior and ‘The Nature of Logic,’” History and Philosophy of Logic, 41(1), 71–81. https://doi.org/10.1080/01445340.2019.1605479
  13. Kenny, A. 1971. “Arthur Norman Prior (1914-1969),” Proceedings of the British Academy, 56, 321–349.
  14. Prior, A. N. 1937. “Revaluationism.” Student, 6, 11.
  15. Prior, A. N. 1940c. Notes on the Westminster confession (and the proposed revision). Unpublished (Typed, 2 pages, + handwritten, 3 pages, Box 7).
  16. Prior, A. N. 1942d. Robert Barclay: Quaker or calvinist?. Unpublished (typed, 15 pp., Box 7).
  17. Prior, A. N. 1946. The reformers reformed: Knox on predestination. The Presbyter, 4, 19–23.
  18. Prior, A. N. 1953. Three-valued logic and future contingents. The Philosophical Quarterly, 3, 317–326. https://doi.org/10.2307/2217099
  19. Prior, A. N. 1957. Time and Modality. Oxford University Press
  20. Prior, A. N. 1958. The good life and religious faith (East-West meeting at Canberra Dec. 1957). Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 36, 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/00048405885200011
  21. Prior, A. N. 2003a. Limited Indeterminism. In P. Hasle, P. Øhrstrøm, T. Braüner, J. Copeland, A.N. Prior, Papers on Time and Tense, 2nd and Ext. Edition (pp. 73 - 79)., Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  22. Prior, A. N. 2003b Formalities of Omniscience. In P. Hasle, P. Øhrstrøm, T. Braüner, J. Copeland, A.N. Prior, Papers on Time and Tense, 2nd and Ext. Edition (pp. 39 - 58)., Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  23. Prior, A. N. 2014a. “Determinism in philosophy and in theology,” in Øhrstrøm, P., Hasle, P., & Jakobsen, D. (Eds.), The Nachlass of A.N. Prior. https://nachlass.prior.aau.dk/paper/determinism-in-philosophy-and-in-theology
  24. Prior, A. N. 2014b. “Reactions to determinism,” in Hasle, P., Øhrstrøm, P., & Jakobsen, D. (Eds.), The Nachlass of A.N. Prior. https://nachlass.prior.aau.dk/paper/reactions-to-determinism
  25. Prior, A. N. 2014c. “Some Free Thinking about Time.” The Nachlass of A.N. Prior. http://nachlass.prior.aau.dk/some-free-thinking-about-time
  26. Prior, A. N. 2020a. “Essay on religion,” in [9]
  27. Prior, A. N. 2020b “Essay on science,” in [9]
  28. Smith, P. 2023. Arthur Prior in the 1940s: Letters and un-published works of Prior 1946-1949. Master thesis, Massey University, Manawatu, New Zealand.
  29. Øhrstrøm P., & Hasle P., 1995. Temporal Logic: From Ancient Ideas to Artificial Intelligence, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Springer Verlag. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-585-37463-5