Articles
Published 13-01-2025
Keywords
- A.N. Prior,
- theology,
- public-intellectual,
- Presbyterianism,
- Catholicism
- Politics,
- Philosophy,
- Belief,
- New Zealand ...More
How to Cite
Grimshaw, M. (2025). Prior as Naphtali: Christian commentator and pseudonymous Christian public intellectual. Logic and Philosophy of Time, 6(1). https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v6i1.9940
Copyright (c) 2025 Logic and Philosophy of Time

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Abstract
During 1951-1952 Arthur Prior wrote a column of firstly public comment, and then, in 1952, theological discussion under the nom-de plume Naphtali of the Outlook, the magazine of the New Zealand Presbyterian Church. This article discusses these columns, putting them in a wider discussion of Prior’s life, thought and Christian beliefs; and his early work in New Zealand as a public thinker.
References
- Beaglehole, J.C. 1954. The New Zealand Scholar, Margaret Condliffe Memorial Lecture, Canterbury University College.
- Copeland, B.J. 2022. "Arthur Prior", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2022 Edition), Edward N. Zalta & Uri Nodelman (eds.), URL = https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2022/entries/prior/
- Grimshaw, M. 2018. Arthur Prior - 'A Young Progressive': Letters to Ursula Bethell & Hugh Teague 1936-1941, Canterbury University Press.
- Grimshaw, M. (2020). ‘The Public Prior: A.N. Prior as (relocated 17th & 18th century) Public Intellectual 1945-1952’, in Halse, P., Jakobsen, D. & Øhrstrøm, P., The Metaphysics of time: Themes from Prior. Aalborg University Press, Logic & Philosophy of Time, Vol.4., pp.25-61. 5. Grimshaw, M. 2021. “From Flower-Show to ‘Praying Scientist’: the Early Thought of Arthur Prior”, in Jakobsen, D., Øhrstrøm, P., Prior, M. & Rini, A.(ed) Three Little Essays: Arthur Prior in 1931. Aalborg University Press, Logic & Philosophy of Time, Vol.3., pp.29-53.
- Grimshaw, M. 2023a. ‘Arthur Prior’s nom de plume writings in Tomorrow and the Otago Daily Times 1935-1937’, Logic and Philosophy of Time vol. 5.pp.1-30 https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v5i1.7832
- Grimshaw, M. 2023b. Arthur Prior. A Calvinist route to Logic, Logic and Philosophy of Time vol. 5 pp.1-23. https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v5i1.7860
- Grimshaw, M. 2023c. ‘To write and think ‘in his own tongue’: Arthur Prior, Jack Bates & the New Zealand Journal of Theology’, Logic and Philosophy of Time vol. 5 pp.1-38. https://doi.org/10.54337/lpt.v5i1.7862
- Grimshaw, M. 2024a. ‘The Prior-Brasch Landfall Letters (1946-1958)’, Logic and Philosophy of Time, vol. 6. pp
- Jakobsen, D. (2012).“An introduction to 'faith, unbelief and evil”, Synthese, Vol. 188, No. 3, (October), pp. 399-409.
- Jakobsen, D. 2016. ‘An Illusion Close to Life’, Synthese, vol. 193, pp. 3429–3439.
- Jakobsen, D. 2020. ‘Dispelling the Freudian Specter: A.N. Prior's Discussion of Religion in 1943’ Logic and Philosophy of Time, vol. 4, pp. 63-86.
- Kenny, A. 1970. ‘Arthur Norman Prior’, Proceedings of the British Academy, vol. LVI, pp. 321–349.
- Markoska-Cubrinovska, A. 2016. “Possible worlds in ‘The Craft of Formal Logic’”. Synthese 193 (11).
- McEldowney, D. 1957/1976. The World Regained. John McIndoe.
- McEldowney, D. 1966. Donald Anderson. A Memoir. Blackwood and Janet Paul.
- McIntyre Jr, R. 1951. “His Voice–Or Our Ears?”, The Outlook August 14, p.10.
- Prior, A.N. 1932. “Christianity and Communism”, Open Windows, vol.1 no.6 October, pp.19-20.
- Prior, A.N. 1942. “How Barth might reply to Professor Allan”, the Student, May, p.7.
- Prior, A.N. 1950a. Current Comment, Naphtali, The Outlook, February 22, p.8.
- Prior, A.N. 1950b. Current Comment, Naphtali, The Outlook, March 8, p.10.
- Prior, A.N. 1950c. “South Africa mainly”. Current Comment, Naphtali, The Outlook March 22, p.8
- Prior, A.N. 1950d. “Who made the welfare state?”, Naphtali, Current Comment, The Outlook April 5, p.15.
- Prior, A.N. 1950e. “How to meet and treat communists”, Naphtali, Current Comment, The Outlook, April 26, p.6.
- Prior, A.N. 1951a. “Why Baptize Babies?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, March 13, p.5
- Prior, A.N. 1951b. “Authority?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, March 20, p.6.
- Prior, A.N. 1951c. “Protestant?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, March 27, p.10.
- Prior, A.N. 1951d. “Wine into Water?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, April 3, pp.6-7.
- Prior, A.N. 1951e. “Why Presbyterian?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, April 10, pp.6-7.
- Prior, A.N. 1951f. “Letters to Naphtali”, Naphtali, The Outlook, April 17, p.12 ‘Fruit of the Vine’.
- Prior, A.N. 1951g. “Silence on heaven”, Naphtali, The Outlook, April 24, pp. 6-7.
- Prior, A.N. 1951h. “As Thyself”, Naphtali, The Outlook, May 1, p.10.
- Prior, A.N. 1951i. “What Difference?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, May 8, pp.5-6.
- Prior, A.N. 1951j. “Wherein Do They Offend?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, June 19, p.14.
- Prior, A.N. 1951k. “Sack Pacifists?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, May 15, pp.9-10.
- Prior, A.N. 1951l. “Response to letter “Sack Pacifists?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, June 19, p.15.
- Prior, A.N. 1951m. “Word of God?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, June 5, pp.6-7.
- Prior, A.N. 1951n. “Jesus a Socialist?”, Naphtali, The Outlook June 12, p.8.
- Prior, A.N. 1951o. “Matter disproved?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, June 26, p.6.
- Prior, A.N. 1951p. “Why Doctrine?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, July 3, pp.6,8.
- Prior, A.N. 1951q. “Why Christ?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, July 10, p.15.
- Prior, A.N. 1951r. “Pie in the Sky?” Naphtali, The Outlook, July 31, p.10.
- Prior, A.N. 1951s. “Women Elders?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, August 7, pp.6-7.
- Prior, A.N. 1951t. “Naphtali Replies”, Naphtali, The Outlook, August 14, p.11.
- Prior, A.N. 1951u. “Are Elders Ministers?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, August 28, p.5.
- Prior, A.N. 1951v. “The Ethical Copula”, The Australasian Journal of Philosophy vol xxix December, no.3, pp.137-154.
- Prior, A.N. 1951w. “Result or Motive?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, October 16, p.11.
- Prior, A.N. 1951x, “Which Church?”, Naphtali, The Outlook, October 23, p.6.
- Report of the Public Questions Committee, in Report Proceedings of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of New Zealand, held in Timaru November 1949, Dunedin, 1950, p.178.
- Report of the Public Questions Committee, in Report Proceedings of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of New Zealand, held in Auckland November 1950, Dunedin, 1950, p.210.
- Report of the Public Questions Committee, in Report Proceedings of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of New Zealand, held in Dunedin October-November 1951, Dunedin, 1950, p.284.
- Richards, A.M. 1950, “Outlook Commentators…” The Outlook, February 22, p.8.
- Richards, A.M. 1951. “Immoral Morality”, The Outlook, March 15, p.4